Why Canadian Youth Are Choosing Poilievre Over Carney

6 min read
0 views
Apr 21, 2025

Canadian youth are fed up with soaring rents and economic stagnation. Pierre Poilievre’s bold promises are winning them over—but will it be enough to topple Carney’s Liberals?

Financial market analysis from 21/04/2025. Market conditions may have changed since publication.

Have you ever stood in the rain for something you truly believed in? For 29-year-old Giancarlo, a Vancouverite braving a soggy March evening, that moment came at a political rally. He wasn’t there for the usual promises of greener policies or social reforms. Instead, he was drawn to a new voice in Canadian politics—one that’s striking a chord with a generation fed up with skyrocketing rents and shrinking dreams. This isn’t just a story about one rally; it’s about a seismic shift among Canada’s youth, who are turning their backs on the Liberal establishment and rallying behind Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre.

A Generational Divide in Canadian Politics

The political landscape in Canada is undergoing a transformation, and it’s not just about red versus blue. For years, young Canadians leaned left, captivated by progressive ideals and charismatic leaders. But something’s changed. The soaring cost of living, unattainable homeownership, and a sense that the system is rigged against them have left Millennials and Gen Z disillusioned. Enter Pierre Poilievre, a politician who’s tapping into this frustration with a style that feels fresh, relatable, and unapologetically bold.

Meanwhile, the Liberal Party, now led by Mark Carney, is banking on a different crowd. At 60, Carney’s polished resume—former governor of the Bank of Canada and Bank of England—resonates with older voters who crave stability. But for younger generations, his nostalgic campaign ads and references to cultural touchstones like The Tragically Hip feel like a disconnect. It’s a generational divide that’s reshaping the electoral map, and the stakes couldn’t be higher as the election looms.


Why Youth Are Flocking to Poilievre

Poilievre’s rise among young voters isn’t just a fluke; it’s a calculated response to their pain points. Unlike the traditional politician in a stuffy suit, Poilievre has embraced the digital age. Picture this: a Conservative leader in aviators, puffing hookah at a shawarma shop, chatting crypto with the owner on YouTube. It’s not your grandpa’s campaign strategy, and that’s the point. His message—cut taxes, slash red tape, and empower savings—hits home for a generation drowning in debt and priced out of the housing market.

It’s time for a change. The same old promises aren’t cutting it anymore.

– Giancarlo, 29-year-old rally attendee

Recent polls reflect this shift. According to data from a leading research firm, 39% of Canadians aged 18 to 34 now support the Conservatives, compared to 36% for the Liberals. That’s a tight race, but it’s a far cry from the days when young voters were a Liberal stronghold. Poilievre’s ability to speak directly to their struggles—rents that eat half their paycheck, groceries that feel like a luxury—has given him an edge. But it’s not just about economics; it’s about vibe. His swagger, his rejection of elite jargon, and his willingness to call out the status quo resonate in a way that feels authentic.

The Liberal Struggle: Carney’s Boomer Appeal

On the other side of the ring, Mark Carney is playing a different game. His campaign leans heavily on experience and nostalgia, targeting Baby Boomers who remember a time when Canada felt more predictable. Ads featuring Carney alongside cultural icons like Mike Myers, reminiscing about classic TV shows, have struck a chord with voters like Tracy, a 64-year-old who switched to the Liberals for Carney’s steady hand. “He’s calm, thoughtful, and I trust him,” she says. It’s a sentiment shared by many in her age group, who see Carney as a safe bet in turbulent times.

But for younger voters, Carney’s approach feels like a relic. His references to 90s Canadiana don’t land with a generation that’s more TikTok than MuchMusic. Worse, the Liberal record—despite wins like pharmacare and dental care—hasn’t solved the housing crisis or eased the cost-of-living crunch. For every policy victory, there’s a renter wondering how they’ll make next month’s payment. It’s a disconnect that’s proving costly as the election nears.


The Gender Gap: A Tale of Two Campaigns

One of the most striking aspects of this election is the gender divide. Polls show that women are twice as likely to support Carney’s Liberals, while nearly half of male voters are backing Poilievre. Why the split? Some point to Poilievre’s style, which critics call coded masculine. His blunt rhetoric, focus on economic freedom, and even his casual wardrobe scream a kind of populist machismo that resonates more with men. A recent speech where he mentioned the “biological clock” in the context of housing affordability sparked backlash, with Liberals accusing him of insensitivity.

Poilievre’s style is bold, but it can alienate those who don’t vibe with its intensity.

– Political science professor

Carney, by contrast, projects a more inclusive, measured tone that appeals to women voters. His focus on social programs and stability aligns with priorities often associated with female voters, though that’s not to say it’s universal. The gender gap highlights a broader challenge: how do you unite a country when different groups are drawn to such contrasting visions?

The Viral Moment: Boomers vs. Zoomers

If you’ve been on social media lately, you’ve probably seen the memes. Elderly Liberal supporters chanting slogans and making defiant gestures have become the internet’s latest obsession. One video, showing a white-haired voter flipping off a crowd, has been dubbed the “mating call of the Boomer Liberal.” It’s funny, sure, but it’s also a symbol of the growing rift between generations. Young Canadians see these moments as proof that the Liberal base is out of touch, more concerned with preserving their own comfort than addressing the struggles of the next generation.

I’ll admit, I chuckled at the memes, but there’s something deeper at play. These viral moments aren’t just about one cranky voter; they’re a reflection of a Liberal campaign that’s leaning too heavily on an aging demographic. Poilievre’s team, meanwhile, is capitalizing on this divide, using social media to amplify their message and paint the Liberals as yesterday’s news.


The Issues That Matter Most

At the heart of this political upheaval are the issues driving voters to the polls. For young Canadians, the top concerns are clear:

  • Housing affordability: With home prices out of reach, many feel locked out of the market.
  • Cost of living: From groceries to gas, everyday expenses are squeezing budgets.
  • Economic opportunity: Stagnant wages and job insecurity are dimming future prospects.

Poilievre has made these issues his battle cry, promising to streamline government, reduce taxes, and boost housing construction. His critics argue that his plans lack detail, but for voters like Giancarlo, the specifics matter less than the intent. “I just want someone who gets it,” he says. Carney’s Liberals, meanwhile, are touting their progressive achievements, but for many young voters, those wins feel overshadowed by the daily grind of survival.

Can Poilievre Close the Gap?

With the election just weeks away, the question remains: can Poilievre’s youth surge translate into victory? The Liberals still hold a slight lead, thanks to their Boomer base and Carney’s steady image. But the momentum is with Poilievre, whose ability to connect with a disillusioned generation could tip the scales. It’s a high-stakes gamble, and the outcome will shape Canada’s future for years to come.

Perhaps the most fascinating aspect of this race is what it reveals about our priorities. Are we a country that clings to the past, or one that’s ready to take a chance on change? For young Canadians, the answer seems clear. They’re tired of waiting for a system that’s failed them, and they’re betting on a leader who promises to shake things up. Whether that bet pays off, only time will tell.


What’s Next for Canada?

As the campaign trail heats up, both sides are doubling down. Poilievre is hitting the road, rallying crowds with his populist flair, while Carney is leaning into policy-heavy speeches aimed at reassuring voters. The contrast couldn’t be starker, and it’s making for one of the most compelling elections in recent memory.

For me, the real story isn’t just about who wins—it’s about what this shift means for Canada’s future. Will young voters continue to demand change, or will the pull of tradition win out? One thing’s for sure: the rain-soaked rallies, viral memes, and heated debates are just the beginning. Canada is at a crossroads, and the choices we make now will echo for generations.

Prosperity is not without many fears and distastes, and adversity is not without comforts and hopes.
— Francis Bacon
Author

Steven Soarez passionately shares his financial expertise to help everyone better understand and master investing. Contact us for collaboration opportunities or sponsored article inquiries.

Related Articles