Medline Stock Too Expensive After IPO Surge, Expert Says

6 min read
2 views
Dec 17, 2025

Medline just pulled off the biggest IPO in years, with shares rocketing more than 41% on day one. Everyone's excited—but one seasoned market watcher says it's gotten a bit too expensive to jump in now. Is this healthcare giant worth chasing at these levels, or should smart investors hold off for a dip? The answer might surprise you...

Financial market analysis from 17/12/2025. Market conditions may have changed since publication.

Have you ever watched a stock absolutely explode out of the gate on its first trading day, only to wonder if all that excitement has already priced in the good news? That’s exactly the vibe surrounding one of the biggest market debuts we’ve seen in years—a medical supplies powerhouse that just went public and left investors buzzing.

It was a blockbuster event, raising billions and seeing shares surge right from the opening bell. But here’s the thing: sometimes the hottest starts can make a stock feel just a tad overcooked. One well-known market commentator recently shared some candid thoughts, suggesting it might be smart to pump the brakes before diving in headfirst.

A Record-Breaking Debut That Turned Heads

Let’s set the scene. This company, a giant in the medical supplies space, managed to pull off the largest initial public offering in over four years. We’re talking serious money—billions flowing in, making it the top IPO globally for the year. When the stock hit the market, it didn’t just open higher; it rocketed upward, climbing more than 40% in a single session.

That’s the kind of performance that grabs headlines and gets trading floors buzzing. In fact, it opened significantly above its initial pricing, reflecting huge demand from investors eager to get a piece of the action. No surprise there—this isn’t some flashy startup; it’s an established player with a solid track record in a recession-resistant industry.

But as thrilling as that first-day pop feels, it often leaves seasoned observers scratching their heads about valuation. When shares run that hard, that fast, you have to ask: has the market already baked in all the upside?

Understanding the Business Behind the Buzz

To really get why this debut mattered so much, you need to peek under the hood at what the company actually does. Think of it as a one-stop shop for healthcare providers—supplying everything from surgical gear to everyday medical essentials. They’ve built a model that’s part warehouse club, part branded manufacturer, offering membership perks and their own high-quality private-label products.

Interestingly, their revenue streams are pretty balanced. Roughly half comes from distributing products across the industry, handling logistics and supply chain needs for hospitals and clinics. The other half? Selling their own manufactured items, which often come with better margins. It’s a smart setup that gives them leverage in a fragmented market.

Over the past few years, they’ve delivered consistent growth. We’re talking low double-digit revenue increases year after year, backed by real profitability. In an era where many companies chase growth at all costs, showing actual earnings feels refreshingly old-school—and reassuring for potential shareholders.

In many ways, it’s like the bulk-buying warehouse for the medical world—reliable, cost-effective, and increasingly indispensable.

That stability in healthcare spending helps explain the investor enthusiasm. Hospitals aren’t going to suddenly stop needing gloves, gowns, or procedure kits, no matter what the economy does.

Why the Valuation Feels Stretched Right Now

Here’s where things get interesting. Despite all the positives—the growth, the profits, the defensive nature of the business—some experts are waving a caution flag after that massive first-day run-up.

Quick math on the current pricing puts the stock trading at around 45 times estimated earnings. For context, that’s a pretty rich multiple, especially for a company growing revenue in the low teens. Sure, healthcare can command premiums, but when shares jump 40%+ overnight, you’re essentially paying up for future growth that’s already reflected in the price.

I’ve seen this movie before. Hot IPOs often deliver spectacular debuts, only to cool off as reality sets in. Not saying this one will crash—far from it—but chasing momentum at peak excitement rarely feels like the best long-term strategy.

  • Strong demand drove the oversubscription and higher opening price
  • First-day gains locked in big paper profits for early holders
  • Current multiple leaves little margin of safety for new buyers
  • Growth trajectory is solid but not explosive enough to justify sky-high valuations

Perhaps the smartest play is patience. Waiting for a pullback to levels closer to the original IPO price could offer a much more attractive entry point.

The Debt Picture and Balance Sheet Realities

No company is perfect, and this one carries some baggage that deserves a closer look. Like many private-equity-backed firms going public, it has a meaningful debt load on the books. Management has acknowledged the need to pay that down over time, which makes sense—lower leverage means more flexibility and less interest expense eating into profits.

The debt isn’t crippling by any stretch. The business generates plenty of cash to service it, and the healthcare sector’s stability helps. Still, in a higher interest rate environment, carrying extra leverage isn’t ideal. Investors will want to track how aggressively the company tackles deleveraging post-IPO.

On the bright side, using some of those fresh IPO proceeds to strengthen the balance sheet could be a positive catalyst down the road. It’s just one more reason why waiting a bit might reveal whether management prioritizes smart capital allocation.

Private Equity Overhang: The Elephant in the Room

If there’s one factor that often puts a lid on post-IPO performance, it’s the presence of large pre-IPO shareholders—particularly private equity firms. In this case, those sponsors control the majority of voting power and hold substantial stakes.

That’s not unusual, but it creates what’s known as an “overhang.” At some point, those investors will look to exit, distributing shares into the market and potentially pressuring the price. The lock-up periods delay this, so near-term selling pressure might be minimal.

Longer term, though? It’s almost inevitable. Private equity doesn’t hold forever; their business model relies on successful exits. Until those positions are largely unwound, the stock could face periodic headwinds whenever blocks hit the market.

These big shareholders will eventually want to realize their gains—and that could create selling pressure down the line.

Smart investors often wait for that overhang to clear before getting aggressive. It’s not about predicting the exact timing; it’s about avoiding unnecessary volatility.

What Would Make This Stock More Attractive?

Don’t get me wrong—this isn’t a bearish take. The underlying business looks robust, with defensive characteristics that should hold up well across economic cycles. If shares retrace toward the IPO pricing zone, say down into the low 30s or even high 20s, the risk/reward flips dramatically in buyers’ favor.

At those levels, you’d be looking at a much more reasonable multiple—perhaps in the 30s—while still capturing the same growth and profitability story. Plus, any progress on debt reduction or clearer visibility on private equity plans would add conviction.

  1. Watch for post-IPO consolidation and potential pullbacks
  2. Monitor quarterly reports for debt paydown progress
  3. Track insider and sponsor selling once lock-ups expire
  4. Reassess valuation against peers in the healthcare supply space
  5. Consider building a position gradually on weakness

In my experience, the best opportunities often come after the initial frenzy dies down. Patience can turn a frothy debut into a compelling long-term holding.

Broader Lessons from This IPO Frenzy

Zooming out, this debut reminds us how emotional markets can get around new listings. The fear of missing out drives massive oversubscription, pushing prices higher and higher—until gravity eventually asserts itself.

It’s classic psychology: everyone wants in when something’s hot, but the easy money often gets made by those who buy before the crowd or wait for the dust to settle. Healthcare stocks, in particular, can trade at premiums because of their stability, but even they aren’t immune to valuation discipline.

Whether you’re eyeing this specific name or just watching the broader IPO pipeline, the takeaway is clear. Strong companies deserve attention, but entry price matters immensely over the long haul. Sometimes doing nothing—waiting for a better pitch—is the most active decision an investor can make.

As always, the market rewards those who keep emotions in check and focus on fundamentals. This medical supplies leader has plenty going for it; the question is simply whether today’s price reflects that fairly.


At the end of the day, great businesses become great investments only when bought at reasonable prices. If this one dips back toward its roots, it could offer exactly that kind of opportunity. Until then, staying on the sidelines doesn’t mean missing out—it might just mean playing the longer, smarter game.

What do you think—would you chase the momentum or wait for a cooler entry? The market’s full of choices, and sometimes the best one is simply holding cash until the odds tilt more clearly in your favor.

We should remember that there was never a problem with the paper qualities of a mortgage bond—the problem was that the house backing it could go down in value.
— Michael Lewis
Author

Steven Soarez passionately shares his financial expertise to help everyone better understand and master investing. Contact us for collaboration opportunities or sponsored article inquiries.

Related Articles

?>