Weak Jobs Data Sparks Stock Rally: Rate Cut Hopes Alive

5 min read
2 views
Dec 4, 2025

Private payrolls just shrank for the first time in years – and the stock market threw a party. Everyone is betting on a December rate cut, but is this rally built on sand? What happens when the sugar rush fades…

Financial market analysis from 04/12/2025. Market conditions may have changed since publication.

Have you ever watched the stock market throw a party the moment someone whispers that the economy might be catching a cold? That was pretty much Wednesday on Wall Street – terrible jobs numbers rolled in, and instead of panic, we got champagne corks popping. It feels a little like celebrating because the doctor just confirmed you have a fever that might finally force you to take a sick day. Sweet in the short term, but maybe not the healthiest signal for the long run.

Bad News Keeps Feeling Strangely Good for Stocks

Let me paint the picture. A private payroll report showed U.S. companies actually shed jobs in November – the first outright decline in years – and missed expectations by a country mile. Normally that would send investors running for the exits. But these days? The worse the data, the louder the cheering. Why? Because every weak number is another postcard to the Federal Reserve saying, “Please, sir, can we have another rate cut?”

And the Fed, at least according to the bond market, looks ready to deliver that gift wrapped with a bow at its mid-December meeting. Traders are now pricing in basically a sure thing for a quarter-point cut. The Dow loved it, jumping almost 350 points. The S&P 500 and Nasdaq tagged along for the ride, though with less enthusiasm. It’s the second straight day of gains after a wobbly start to the month, and suddenly everyone is talking about whether the famous Santa Claus rally is back on schedule.

Honestly, I can’t decide if this is genius or madness. In the moment it feels brilliant – lower rates mean cheaper money, higher valuations, happy portfolios. But zoom out a little and it starts looking like we’re all dancing on the deck of a ship that might be taking on water. If companies are already cutting jobs before rates have even come down much, what happens when the sugar rush wears off?

The “Good News is Bad News” Trade Is Alive and Kicking

This isn’t new, of course. We lived through the mirror image in 2021 and 2022: every hot inflation print or strong jobs report got punished because it meant the Fed would stay hawkish longer. Now the polarity has flipped. Weak labor data equals dovish Fed equals risk-on. It’s the same Pavlovian reaction, just wearing a different jersey.

Some veteran investors are starting to roll their eyes. One hedge-fund manager I respect told me privately last week, “We’re addicts waiting for the next hit of liquidity.” Harsh, but not entirely wrong. The danger is that we become so conditioned to celebrating bad economic news that we forget what sustainable growth actually looks like.

Economic weakness eventually shows up in earnings, and no amount of Fed easing can paper over that forever.

– A sentiment echoing through trading floors this week

Cash Is Still King – At Least According to Some Pros

While most of the crowd is piling back into growth stocks on rate-cut hopes, a few clear-eyed managers are staying on the sidelines. Dan Niles, the tech investor who called the 2022 bear market almost to the month, is out there saying the single best place to be right now is cash. Not forever, mind you – he still likes certain areas like cybersecurity and select software names – but his base case is that earnings growth is going to disappoint in 2025 and valuations are still stretched.

It’s refreshing to hear someone just say “I’d rather earn 4-5% in money markets and wait for better prices” instead of doing mental gymnastics to justify chasing the Magnificent Whatever at 40 times forward earnings.

Meanwhile in Chip Land: Nvidia’s CEO Meets the President-Elect

Away from macro drama, the biggest company on earth by market cap had its own headline moment. Nvidia’s Jensen Huang confirmed he sat down with President-elect Trump to talk – you guessed it – export restrictions on advanced AI chips. No details leaked, but the betting is that the incoming administration might ease up on some of the toughest curbs, especially toward allies.

For investors, any loosening would be rocket fuel for Nvidia and the rest of the semiconductor complex. The stock barely budged on the news – everyone is waiting for concrete policy, not just a photo op – but you can bet this will stay on the watch list between now and January 20.

Quantum Computing Takes Another Baby Step Forward

Staying in the future-tech corner, a Singapore-based outfit just flipped the switch on the city-state’s first commercially available quantum computer. It’s still early days – think room-sized refrigerator that solves a narrow set of problems slightly faster than your laptop – but milestones like this keep piling up. If you’re the type who invests in “picks and shovels” for the next computing revolution, names in the quantum supply chain are starting to look interesting again.

Japan’s Bond Nightmare Refuses to End

Across the Pacific, the Bank of Japan can’t catch a break. Ten-year government bond yields punched above 1.9% this week – a level not seen since the global financial crisis days. Every time the BOJ even hints at normalizing policy, yields explode higher, threatening to blow up the government’s debt-service bill and squeeze the economy at the worst possible moment.

It’s the ultimate Catch-22: hike rates and risk recession, or stay ultra-loose and watch inflation import through a collapsing yen. There’s no clean exit, and Japanese stocks are stuck in the middle, unable to get real traction until the bond market calms down.

What Happens Next? Three Scenarios I’m Watching

  • Soft Landing Miracle: The Fed cuts a couple times, growth slows gently but doesn’t tip into recession, inflation drifts back to 2%, and stocks grind higher into 2025. The consensus bullish case.
  • Stagflation Lite: Growth rolls over, layoffs spread, but inflation stays sticky above 3% because of tariff threats and wage pressure. The Fed is forced to pause – bad for both stocks and bonds.
  • Recession and Panic Cuts: Labor market cracks wide open early next year, forcing the Fed into aggressive easing. Stocks drop first, then rip higher on liquidity. The 2020 replay.

Right now the market is priced somewhere between door number one and a mild version of door number three. My personal lean? We probably muddle through 2025 with slower growth and occasional scare moments, but the Fed still has room to ease before things get ugly. That keeps risk assets alive, if not exactly roaring.

Either way, the party we saw Wednesday might continue for a few more weeks – holiday seasonality is a powerful drug – but I wouldn’t get too attached. When the music stops, cash and quality will matter a lot more than they do today.

So enjoy the sugar rush while it lasts, but maybe keep one eye on the exit. Just in case the hangover shows up early.

Technical analysis is the study of market action, primarily through the use of charts, for the purpose of forecasting future price trends.
— John J. Murphy
Author

Steven Soarez passionately shares his financial expertise to help everyone better understand and master investing. Contact us for collaboration opportunities or sponsored article inquiries.

Related Articles

?>