Roundhill Abandons Solana XRP Income ETFs After Heavy Losses

9 min read
0 views
Nov 19, 2026

Roundhill just walked away from its Solana and XRP income ETFs after rivals lost more than half their value. The numbers are brutal and the timing raises bigger questions about whether these products can ever work long-term.

Financial market analysis from 19/11/2026. Market conditions may have changed since publication.

I still remember the first time someone told me crypto income products would change everything. Regular yield from assets that used to just sit there doing nothing sounded almost too good. Then the numbers started rolling in and the picture got a lot messier. Roundhill Investments just pulled the plug on its planned Solana and XRP covered-call ETFs after more than a year of filings and delays. The decision landed on November 18 and, honestly, it did not come as a total shock once you look at what similar products have delivered so far.

Why Roundhill Walked Away From Solana And XRP Income Products

The filings were short and direct. Roundhill ETF Trust told regulators it no longer intends to seek effectiveness for either the Solana Covered Call Strategy ETF or the XRP Covered Call Strategy ETF. Neither product ever sold a single share. The firm had first registered them back in October 2025 and kept pushing the effective dates further out, the last extension aiming for December 2026. Then, without a detailed public explanation, the whole effort was cancelled.

In my view the timing says a lot. Competing funds from Amplify have been live for months and the results look painful. The Solana version, SOLM, and the XRP version, XRPM, together held only about $9 million in assets by mid-November. At the end of October that number sat closer to $12.3 million. Assets dropped more than a quarter in a few weeks even before you factor in pure price action.

The Ugly Performance Numbers Nobody Can Ignore

Here is where it gets uncomfortable. From inception through the end of October, SOLM was down roughly 55.57 percent on a net asset value basis. XRPM sat even lower at a 58.21 percent cumulative loss. Both funds aim for high monthly option income, targeting something like 36 percent annualized premiums by selling weekly calls. Reported distribution rates climbed above 40 percent at one point. Yet total returns stayed deeply negative because the underlying assets kept sliding and the option strategy capped the upside.

That is the classic covered-call trade-off. You collect premium income in exchange for giving up most of the big rallies. When the market trends lower or chops sideways with volatility, the income can help. When the market drops hard and stays soft, you still eat the full downside while the premiums only soften the blow a little. Amplify itself notes that distributions can include return of capital, which is never a great long-term look for investors hoping for pure yield.

Expense ratios sit at 0.75 percent. On the current combined asset base that works out to roughly $67,700 in annualized fees if assets stay flat. Whether that covers the cost of running the funds is an open question, but the bigger issue remains the performance gap between promised income and actual total return.

How Roundhill Planned To Generate Income

Roundhill’s strategy looked familiar if you have followed its Bitcoin and Ether covered-call products. The funds would have kept at least 80 percent of net assets, measured by notional value, in options linked to existing Solana or XRP ETFs or futures-based vehicles. The basic idea was to buy calls and sell puts to create synthetic exposure, then sell additional calls against that exposure to harvest premiums for distribution.

On paper it sounds neat. In practice the liquidity of those options markets is still thin compared with traditional equity options. The prospectuses themselves warned that limited liquidity could make positions expensive to close, delay trades, and sometimes prevent the funds from hitting their objectives. I have watched similar products in other corners of the market struggle with exactly those frictions. When the underlying moves fast, the options book can lag and the income becomes harder to lock in cleanly.


Spot ETFs Tell A Different Story

While income products remain tiny, the plain-vanilla spot Solana and XRP ETFs have attracted real money. Between May and October they pulled in roughly $969 million of net inflows. Combined assets reached about $3.26 billion by the end of October. That is more than 250 times the size of the two Amplify income funds at their recent peak. Institutions appear far more interested in straightforward exposure than in layered option strategies that mute upside.

Recent weeks have cooled that enthusiasm. During one mid-November stretch, Solana spot ETFs saw about $32 million of outflows and XRP products lost another $19 million, the largest weekly redemption for XRP funds in roughly eight months. Still, the absolute size of the spot complex dwarfs the income niche. Investors seem willing to accept volatility when they can capture the full move, but they grow cautious when the product design already limits participation.

What Covered Calls Really Cost Investors

Let me be blunt. Covered-call strategies work best in range-bound or gently rising markets. Crypto rarely behaves that way for long stretches. Solana and XRP have both delivered violent swings. Selling calls against them means you miss the sharp upward spikes that often define multi-month returns in this asset class. At the same time you remain fully exposed when the market decides to drop 20 or 30 percent in a few weeks.

I have seen this pattern before with equity covered-call funds during bull markets. The income looks attractive on a monthly statement until you compare total return against a simple long-only position. Over full cycles the opportunity cost of capped upside tends to dominate. In crypto the effect can be even more pronounced because the biggest gains often arrive in concentrated bursts.

Income is only useful if it does not cost you more in foregone appreciation than it delivers in cash flow.

That simple idea explains a lot of the recent performance gap. Amplify’s funds paid high distribution rates yet still posted deep losses. Investors who needed the cash flow may accept the trade-off. Those who wanted growth exposure have been better served by the spot products, even with their own recent volatility.

Liquidity And Operational Realities

Another quiet problem sits in the options markets themselves. Equity options on major stocks and indexes are deep and continuous. Crypto-linked options, especially those tied to newer ETFs or futures, remain thinner. Spreads widen when volatility spikes. Rolling positions every week becomes more expensive. The funds can end up paying more in transaction costs and slippage than the premium income fully offsets. Prospectuses rarely dwell on this friction in marketing language, yet it shows up in live results over time.

Roundhill already runs successful covered-call products on Bitcoin and Ether. Those underlying markets are larger and the options ecosystems around them more mature. Solana and XRP sit further down the liquidity curve. Launching similar products there carried higher operational risk from day one. Walking away before any capital was committed looks, in hindsight, like a rational risk-management decision rather than a pure marketing retreat.

Broader Lessons For Crypto Income Seekers

Investors keep searching for yield in crypto. Staking, lending, and now option-based ETFs all promise some version of regular cash flow. Each method carries its own set of trade-offs. Staking ties capital to network performance and smart-contract risk. Lending platforms have shown credit and custody problems in the past. Covered-call ETFs trade upside for premium income and introduce options-market frictions.

None of these approaches eliminates the core volatility of the underlying assets. They merely reshape how that volatility appears in a portfolio. When the market trends higher, pure spot exposure usually wins. When it trends lower, income strategies can reduce the pain but rarely reverse it. Sideways markets are the sweet spot for covered calls, yet crypto spends relatively little time in true sideways regimes.

  • High distribution rates look attractive until total return is measured
  • Capped upside hurts most during the sharp rallies that define crypto cycles
  • Thin options liquidity raises hidden costs that erode net income
  • Asset gathering remains difficult when performance lags the simple alternative
  • Spot products continue to attract far larger capital flows

Those five points capture the current reality. Roundhill’s decision simply reflects what the data already showed. Competing products struggled to grow assets and delivered large losses despite elevated distribution rates. Launching two more funds into that environment would have required strong conviction that conditions would improve quickly. Apparently that conviction was not there.

Institutional Behavior Offers Another Clue

Large traditional institutions have shown interest in Solana and XRP, but mostly through direct holdings or plain spot ETFs rather than income wrappers. One major European bank expanded its positions in both assets during the third quarter, bringing the combined value above $40 million. That kind of capital tends to prefer clean exposure and the ability to manage options overlays internally if desired. Packaged retail income products sit lower on the priority list.

Retail investors, meanwhile, often chase the highest advertised yield. The Amplify funds delivered exactly that on a distribution basis yet still lost more than half their value. The gap between marketing language and realized total return creates disappointment and slows further asset growth. Once early adopters experience the full cycle, word travels fast and new money becomes harder to attract.

What Happens Next For Crypto Option Strategies

Roundhill still offers its Bitcoin and Ether covered-call ETFs. Those products benefit from deeper underlying markets and longer track records. Whether the firm eventually returns to Solana or XRP income vehicles will depend on how the options markets evolve and how investor appetite for yield shifts. Right now the evidence points toward patience rather than urgency.

Other issuers may still try. The demand for crypto yield is real. The question is whether the current product designs can satisfy that demand without destroying capital along the way. Improvements in options liquidity, tighter spreads, and perhaps different strike or expiration choices could help. Until those improvements arrive, the performance gap between income products and spot products is likely to remain wide.

I keep coming back to a simple test. If an investor needs the cash flow and fully understands the upside cap, a covered-call fund can serve a purpose. If the investor mainly wants exposure to the asset’s long-term potential, the plain spot ETF remains the cleaner vehicle. Most of the recent capital flows have voted with the second choice.

Risk Management Lessons From The Episode

Asset managers face a delicate balance. Launching products too early risks poor performance and reputational damage. Waiting too long risks missing a window of investor interest. Roundhill’s multi-year filing process and eventual withdrawal suggest a careful approach to that balance. Canceling before any investor capital was at risk protects both the firm and potential shareholders from a product that might have struggled.

For individual investors the episode reinforces the value of reading beyond the yield number. Distribution rate, total return, expense ratio, liquidity of the underlying options, and correlation to the broader crypto market all matter. A 40 percent distribution rate paired with a 55 percent loss is not the same as a 5 percent yield with stable capital. Context is everything.

Perhaps the most interesting aspect is how quickly the narrative can shift. A year ago the idea of Solana and XRP income ETFs felt innovative. Today the same idea looks premature given the performance of the first movers. Markets teach hard lessons. Product design that works in theory often needs several iterations before it works in practice at scale.

Looking At The Bigger Crypto Product Landscape

Spot Bitcoin and Ether ETFs have gathered tens of billions. Newer altcoin spot products are still early but already larger than the income niche. Leveraged and inverse products attract active traders. Income strategies sit in a smaller corner where the math has proven difficult so far. That does not mean the category will disappear. It does mean issuers need better market conditions or smarter structures before the next wave of launches.

Roundhill’s simultaneous withdrawal of a leveraged daily product on the same day further underscores a broader caution. Not every idea that can be filed should be launched. Selective product development protects the brand and the investors who eventually buy the funds that do come to market.

In the end the story is less about one firm’s decision and more about the gap between the promise of crypto yield and the reality of delivering it through listed products. Covered-call strategies remain useful tools in the right environment. Right now that environment for Solana and XRP income funds looks less favorable than the pure exposure alternative. Investors who stay focused on total return rather than headline distribution rates will likely make clearer decisions as the market continues to evolve.

The next few quarters will tell us whether liquidity improves enough to support a second attempt or whether the industry pivots toward different yield approaches entirely. Either way, the recent numbers have set a high bar for any future Solana or XRP income product that wants to succeed where the first ones struggled.

❝
A simple fact that is hard to learn is that the time to save money is when you have some.
— Joe Moore
Author

Steven Soarez passionately shares his financial expertise to help everyone better understand and master investing. Contact us for collaboration opportunities or sponsored article inquiries.

Related Articles

?>