What happens when the biggest stablecoin on the planet starts loading more gold and public stocks into its reserves while a major ratings agency keeps giving it the lowest possible mark for stability? That question sits at the center of the latest assessment of Tether’s USDT. The score stays stuck at the bottom of a five-point scale, and the share of assets the agency labels higher-risk has climbed to 28 percent. On paper the coin still looks over-collateralized. In practice the growing exposure to assets that can swing with market prices has raised fresh eyebrows across the industry.
Why S&P Refuses To Raise USDT’s Stability Score
The latest review leaves USDT exactly where it was a year ago: a score of 5, the weakest level on the scale. This is not a formal credit rating. It is a stability assessment focused on one simple question: how reliably can the token hold its one-dollar peg under stress. The agency looked at the reserve mix as of the end of September and decided the risk profile had not improved enough to justify any upgrade.
Higher-risk assets now represent roughly 28 percent of circulating USDT. That figure stood at 24 percent twelve months earlier. The category includes corporate bonds, secured loans, and other investments sensitive to price swings, interest-rate moves, and borrower credit quality. In the agency’s view a sharp drop in the value of those holdings could leave the stablecoin undercollateralized at exactly the wrong moment.
I have followed these assessments for a while, and the pattern feels familiar. Issuers point to excess reserves and strong recent performance. Rating firms point to concentration in assets that are not pure cash or short-term Treasuries. Both sides talk past each other more often than they meet in the middle.
How The Reserve Mix Shifted Over The Past Year
The composition of Tether’s reserves has changed in noticeable ways. Gold holdings jumped from about $12.9 billion to roughly $19 billion. Public equity investments appeared for the first time and reached $4.2 billion. Bitcoin exposure actually declined, moving from $9.9 billion down to $8.4 billion. Those shifts help explain why the higher-risk bucket expanded even as some crypto-native holdings shrank.
At the same time the company continues to hold a massive position in U.S. Treasury bills and related instruments. Direct and indirect exposure to Treasuries stood near $132.4 billion. That large, liquid core still generates most of the operating income and provides the backbone of the reserve portfolio. The tension comes from the growing slice that sits outside that safe core.
A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized.
That single sentence captures the agency’s core concern. Excess reserves exist, yet the value of the riskier holdings exceeds the size of the surplus buffer. In a severe market downturn the math could turn uncomfortable faster than many holders expect.
The Numbers Behind The Collateral Buffer
As of the end of September, total assets reached $191.45 billion while liabilities stood at $183.50 billion. That produces a collateralization ratio of about 104.3 percent. The excess reserve buffer itself nearly doubled in a single quarter, rising from roughly $4.11 billion at the end of June to $7.95 billion by the end of September. Quarterly net operating profit came in around $1.5 billion, largely powered by interest earned on Treasuries and reverse repurchase agreements.
Those figures look solid on the surface. The surplus provides a cushion. The problem, according to the assessment, is that the absolute size of the higher-risk assets still dwarfs that cushion. If gold, equities, or certain loans experience a coordinated sell-off, the buffer could shrink or even disappear before management has time to rebalance.
Perhaps the most interesting aspect is how little the market seems to care on a day-to-day basis. USDT continues to trade tightly around the dollar. Liquidity on major exchanges remains deep. Redemption demand has not spiked. Still, stability assessments exist precisely for moments when calm markets turn chaotic.
Transparency Gaps That Keep The Score Low
Reserve transparency remains a persistent sticking point. Tether completed its first full independent audit covering the year ended December 31, 2025. The audit firm issued an unqualified opinion and even physically inspected and counted the gold bars. On paper that should have removed a major cloud.
Yet the full financial statements, detailed notes, and the complete auditor’s report have not been made public. Without those documents, outside parties cannot independently verify valuations, ownership chains, or counterparty exposures. Quarterly reserve reports also stop short of naming custodians, banking partners, or specific counterparties. Disclosures around the credit quality of secured loans and corporate bonds remain limited.
In my view this is the part of the story that matters most for long-term confidence. A clean audit is progress. Full public transparency would be a bigger leap. Until more detail becomes available, any stability assessment will almost certainly stay cautious.
Regulatory Home And Its Consequences
Tether relocated its operations to El Salvador in 2025 and now sits under the supervision of that country’s National Commission of Digital Assets. Local rules require at least one dollar of reserve assets for every dollar of stablecoins issued. At least 70 percent of those reserves must be investable in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days.
The framework allows meaningful exposure to Bitcoin, gold, and loans. It also does not impose the same strict segregation requirements found in some European or U.S. proposals. The agency notes that public information is still insufficient to determine how reserves would be protected if the issuer faced insolvency or if non-stablecoin businesses ran into trouble. Those other activities include artificial intelligence projects and Bitcoin mining.
Tether maintains that its non-stablecoin operations are kept separate from USDT reserves. That separation is important. Whether the legal structure provides the same level of protection that more mature regulatory regimes demand is the open question the assessment continues to raise.
Price Stability Versus Redemption Reality
Despite the weak score, the assessment acknowledges that USDT has held its peg remarkably well over the past twelve months. That track record is hard to ignore. Liquidity across centralized and decentralized venues has helped absorb selling pressure without large deviations from the dollar.
Direct redemptions, however, remain restricted. Only verified customers holding at least $100,000 can redeem directly with the issuer. Fees include a verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1 percent, whichever is higher. Payments still follow conventional banking hours. For most holders the real exit door remains the secondary market rather than the issuer’s front desk.
As of late October, Tron hosted about 50.7 percent of circulating USDT, Ethereum roughly 46.8 percent, and Solana around 1.6 percent. Those three networks together account for more than 99 percent of supply. Concentration on a few chains is efficient for users, yet it also creates operational dependencies that any full stability analysis must consider.
What The Rising Risk Allocation Really Means
The jump from 24 percent to 28 percent higher-risk assets is not dramatic in isolation. Context matters. Gold has been a strong performer. Public equities can deliver returns that short-term Treasuries cannot match. For an issuer generating substantial profits, allocating a portion of excess reserves into higher-yielding assets is a rational business decision.
The counter-argument is straightforward. Stablecoins are meant to be boring. Holders use them as a digital dollar substitute, not as a vehicle for the issuer’s investment views. When a larger slice of the reserve base becomes sensitive to market prices, the product starts to look a little less like pure cash and a little more like a managed portfolio with a one-dollar target.
I’ve found that markets usually ignore these nuances until they suddenly matter. Liquidity is high, the peg holds, and daily trading volumes stay large. The real test arrives during a broad risk-off episode when gold, stocks, and certain credit assets all sell at once. That is the scenario the assessment is designed to highlight.
Tether’s Pushback And The Framework Debate
Tether has rejected the findings. Company representatives argue that the methodology itself is flawed and that the problem lies with the evaluation framework rather than the quality of the reserves. They have pointed to past episodes in traditional finance where rating approaches failed to capture real risks, using historical examples to question the current lens.
This disagreement is not new. Similar tensions surfaced the previous year when the score first dropped to the lowest level. The issuer continues to emphasize its excess reserves, profitable operations, and the clean audit opinion. The agency continues to emphasize asset composition, disclosure gaps, and the regulatory environment. Both positions contain elements that careful observers should weigh.
Looking Ahead: What Could Change The Score
Several developments could eventually move the needle. Full public release of the audited financial statements and detailed notes would address a major transparency criticism. A clear reduction in the higher-risk allocation, or stronger evidence that those assets are hedged or highly liquid, would help. Greater clarity around legal segregation of reserves from other business activities would also reduce uncertainty.
On the other side, further growth in gold, equities, or loans without matching increases in the surplus buffer would likely keep the score pinned at the bottom. Any material loss of the dollar peg, even temporary, would obviously confirm the agency’s caution. For now the path of least resistance appears to be an unchanged assessment until more concrete changes appear in the public record.
Stablecoins occupy a unique place in the crypto ecosystem. They power trading, payments, and DeFi activity on a massive scale. When the largest one carries a weak stability score year after year, the industry has to decide how much weight to give that signal. Some participants will keep using USDT because liquidity and network effects dominate. Others may gradually shift toward alternatives that score higher on reserve quality and disclosure metrics.
Practical Takeaways For Market Participants
Holders and traders should understand the difference between daily price stability and structural resilience. The former has been excellent. The latter is what the assessment questions. Diversifying across multiple stablecoins remains a simple risk-management step for anyone holding large balances. Watching the quarterly reserve reports for further shifts in gold, equities, and loans also makes sense.
- Monitor the size of the excess reserve buffer relative to higher-risk assets
- Note any changes in the percentage allocated to gold and public equities
- Watch for public release of full audited financial statements
- Track whether redemption terms or banking relationships evolve
- Compare reserve quality metrics across major stablecoins over time
None of these steps require panic. They simply reflect a mature approach to an asset that underpins a large share of crypto market activity. The score is a signal, not a prophecy. How the issuer responds over the coming quarters will determine whether that signal fades or grows louder.
The Bigger Picture For Stablecoin Trust
Trust in stablecoins ultimately rests on three pillars: transparent reserves, high-quality assets, and reliable redemption. USDT scores well on market liquidity and historical peg performance. It scores less well on the first two pillars according to the latest independent review. Closing that gap would strengthen the entire sector.
Gold and equities can be part of a sophisticated reserve strategy. They can also introduce volatility that pure cash and short-term government securities do not. Finding the right balance is the challenge every major issuer now faces. The latest assessment makes clear that, in at least one influential view, the current mix still sits too far toward the riskier end of the spectrum.
Whether that view eventually changes depends less on marketing and more on verifiable improvements in disclosure and asset quality. Until then the weakest stability score remains attached to the largest stablecoin, and market participants will continue to debate how much that label really matters.
The conversation around reserve composition is unlikely to disappear. As more capital flows into digital dollars, the standards applied to those dollars will keep rising. Issuers that meet higher transparency and quality thresholds early may find themselves better positioned when the next period of market stress arrives. For now USDT continues to dominate trading volumes while carrying the lowest mark on the stability scale. That combination is unusual, and it is worth watching closely.